Which car rusts the worst? The data is in and it’s eye-popping.

3 hours ago 23
Andy Enright
Which car rusts the worst? The data is in and it’s eye-popping.

Gone are the days when a new car would start oxidising before your eyes as soon as it left a dealer forecourt, but if you're shopping for a used car, it helps to know which will rust quickest.

We've had plenty of anecdotal evidence down the years of cars that bought cheap Russian steel or which skimped on rustproofing, or even which sat awaiting deliveries up to their axles in water, but we've never had an absolutely bulletproof and unarguable data set. Until now.

British company PlateInsight has analysed the results of 3,142,385 roadworthy tests in order to bring you the facts about which cars were failing the MOT (Ministry of Transport) tests on corrosion-based issues. Overall, it assessed over 261 million data points.

Fortunately, almost all of the noteworthy cars are also sold in Australia, so the data translates fairly well.

What's more, the gulf between the best and worst performers is eye-popping. The 2011 Suzuki SX4 diesel win the dubious honour of metal-moth champion, with corrosion-related defects evident in over 71 per cent of MOT tests.

2011 Suzuki SX4 Crossover S AWD Review

2011 Suzuki SX4 Crossover S AWD Review

At the other extreme, the 2019 Ford Fiesta scored a barely-there 0.18% defect rate. So while one of these cars will have you checking out your local TAFE for welding classes, the other seems about as impervious to the effects of salty water as a Phillip Island penguin.

PalteInsight has rather helpfully ranked the 20 rustiest cars and the 20 most corrosion-resistant models that were submitted in statistically signifcant numbers for MOT testing.

The data reveals a few interesting correlations. It's clear which brands skimp on rustproofing, how higher mileage affects the rate of rust, and why some cheap cars fare worse than premium alternatives. If you're shopping for a used car, this is something you'll want to pay attention to, as rust can seriously compromise the safety of your car.

Here's the list of the most rust-prone cars in the UK.

POSITIONVEHICLEDEFECT RATECORROSION OCCURRENCESMOT TESTSEARLIEST OCCURRENCE (MILES)MEDIAN MILEAGEMILEAGE PER YEAR
12011 Suzuki SX4 diesel71.12%4849681866,871104,0486897
22013 Dacia Duster diesel67.33%55,22982,02764,85859,5757517
32012 Suzuki SX4 diesel64.71%3966612964,42060,7446779
42013 Dacia Duster petrol63.23%5258831656,01751,9626500
52010 Suzuki SX4 petrol58.66%21,24836,22360,82156,9205920
62012 Suzuki SX4 petrol56.13%13,67524,36352,02447,3495535
72011 Suzuki SX4 petrol56.01%17,79631,77557,69153,2195703
82014 Dacia Duster diesel55.18%34,31662,18861,90957,3607344
92010 Suzuki Swift diesel54.90%3575651275,19971,3767248
102010 Mitsubishi Lancer diesel53.73%11,51121,42281,38778,5328669
112010 Mitsubishi Outlander diesel53.72%15,14928,20191,84189,4228820
122010 Citroen C-Crosser diesel53.46%4735885784,78381,3338456
132011 Mitsubishi Outlander diesel51.86%12,38423,88187,00385,4388498
142010 Suzuki Swift petrol51.78%58,557113,09159,80956,4875790
152010 Kia Sorento diesel50.21%18,54536,93478,13076,0408008
162012 MG6 petrol49.82%3796761957,60354,3086352
172013 Suzuki SX4 diesel49.63%4032812464,44658,1207624
182010 Toyota Urban Cruiser diesel48.78%4847993767,19562,5596950
19 2012 Mitsubishi Outlander diesel48.57%854817,59878,13474,6488,384
202014 Dacia Duster petrol48.40%3425707649,34844,6166140

The two key offenders are clear. The Suzuki SX4 and Dacia Duster models from 2010-2014 rust at a rate greater than any others, scoring defect rates above 48%.

Now let's have a look at the cars that absolutely aced the assignment.

POSITIONVEHICLEDEFECT RATECORROSION OCCURRENCESMOT TESTSEARLIEST OCCURRENCE (MILES)MEDIAN MILEAGEMILEAGE PER YEAR
12019 Ford Fiesta petrol0.18%589334,89130,20527,0856100
22017 BMW 320 diesel0.25%20079,34262,98658,3588946
32019 Mini Cooper petrol0.26%356135,86627,77524,6145710
42019 Ford Ecosport petrol0.27%304113,56827,05824,2275424
52019 Ford Focus petrol0.27%531193,88434,11731,2747100
62018 Ford Focus petrol0.29%1535528,52434,87432,1506068
72019 Skoda Fabia petrol0.29%20369,32029,77726,4486094
82018 Hyundai Tucson petrol0.30%333110,87837,07434,2747158
92016 BMW 118 petrol0.31%21468,36144,09340,9166288
102018 Mercedes-Benz E-Class diesel0.31%335108,35859,27346,0349662
112020 Nissan Qashqai petrol0.32%321101,11630,82528,6666864
122016 BMW 116 petrol0.33%328100,43662,14158,4948309
132018 Toyota Prius hybrid0.35%26274,69677,41763,90817,490
142020 BMW 118 petrol0.36%20355,68531,46428,7487348
152019 Toyota C-HR hybrid0.36%25671,50739,62433,8807646
162016 BMW 420 diesel0.37%27073,35463,21057,6888567
172017 Kia Sportage 20170.37%373101,48442,10939,0467056
182018 Toyota C-HR hybrid0.37%33891,69144,00439,1827473
192017 Toyota Prius hybrid0.37%34391,72087,10069,35517,743
202017 Honda Civic petrol0.38%34590,71338,61034,7146146

The key takeaway here is that contempora Fords, BMWs, and Toyotas (from 2017 ) display vastly better rustproofing than the worst of the worst.

Other points jump out. One is the sheer number of data points, with over half a million Ford Focus tests analysed.

Another is the amount of miles that Brits pile onto Toyota Priuses. Put that down to the ride-share gig economy.

PlateInsight was curious as to why the Suzuki SX4 was such a catastrophic performer and identified a number of reasons. They included inadequate cavity waxing and thin underbody coating that was overmatched by the 'perfect storm' of UK corrosion conditions; winter salt applications and persistent humidity.

The SX4 saw corrosion centre on the rear subframe mounting points and inner sill sections. Water enters through drainage holes that become blocked with road debris, then sits against bare metal. The data seems to show that diesel models fare worse statistically, because they tend to cover higher mileages.

Early Dacia Duster (not the new version imported to Australia) recorded rusty brake lines, corroded springs and then structural issues around the suspension mounts.

At the other end of the scale, the Ford Fiesta excelled. That's because Ford uses fully galvanised steel on all body panels and subframes from 2017 onwards, with the backup of twelve-year anti-perforation warranties. Underbody protection is also excellent, with a wax-based cavity seal injected into sills, door frames, and chassis rails. It clearly works in the most unforgiving corrosion environment on Earth.

Andy Enright

Andy brings almost 30 years automotive writing experience to his role at Drive. When he wasn’t showing people which way the Nürburgring went, he freelanced for outlets such as Car, Autocar, and The Times. After contributing to Top Gear Australia, Andy subsequently moved Down Under, serving as editor at MOTOR and Wheels. As Drive’s Road Test Editor, he’s at the heart of our vehicle testing, but also loves to spin a long-form yarn.

Read more about Andy EnrightLinkIcon

Read Entire Article
| | | |